What happens when payroll and compliance don’t talk to each other
22.05.2026Payroll and compliance are two sides of the same coin. One pays people correctly, the other proves to the regulator that everything has been done by the book. When they work together, the business runs quietly in the background. When they don’t, things start to fall apart in ways that aren’t always obvious until it’s too late.
A lot of firms don’t realise their payroll and compliance systems aren’t really connected until something goes wrong. A figure doesn’t match across two reports. A deadline gets missed because the numbers weren’t ready in time. An auditor or regulator asks a question that should take ten minutes to answer and instead takes three days.
This is what happens when payroll and compliance live in separate worlds.
The everyday symptoms
When your payroll system and your regulatory reporting don’t share the same source of truth, the cracks show up in small ways first.
You end up rekeying numbers from one place to another. You keep a spreadsheet “just to tie things together”. You spend the last week of every reporting period chasing figures that should already be sitting in front of you. None of it feels like a crisis on its own, but the time and risk add up quickly.
For IFAs, this is especially painful around RegData reporting. The figures you need are scattered across your bookkeeping, your client records and whatever notes you’ve made through the year. Pulling it all together becomes a job in itself and it’s a job that has to be done right, because the FCA is on the other end of it. We’ve written before about why RMAR reporting takes hours when it really shouldn’t, and the root cause is almost always the same: disconnected data.
Where the real risk sits
Errors are the obvious risk, but they’re not the most damaging one. The bigger problem is the time and attention disconnected systems eat up.
If you’re running an IFA practice, every hour spent wrestling with RegData is an hour not spent with clients. If you’re running a small business, every hour spent fixing payroll mistakes is an hour not spent growing the business. We covered this in more detail in the hidden cost of doing payroll manually, but the same principle applies to compliance work , the cost is rarely the fine, it’s everything else you weren’t doing.
Then there’s the audit trail problem. When data is moved by hand between systems, you lose the clean record of where each figure came from. That’s fine until someone asks you to prove it. HMRC, the FCA, your accountant, your auditor, they all want to see a chain of evidence, and a chain that runs through three spreadsheets and an inbox isn’t a chain anyone wants to defend.
Why purpose-built software matters
The fix isn’t to bolt your payroll system to your compliance system. It’s to use software that’s been built for the job in the first place, so the data is clean from the start.
MyRegData is built for directly authorised IFAs who need to produce a RegData Report without it taking over their week. It handles every section of the RMAR, A through K, plus Complaints and FIN073 and submits directly to the FCA. Bookkeeping is built in, so the numbers feeding your report aren’t sitting in a separate system you have to reconcile. Your accountant can have a free login to work alongside you, which removes another common point of friction.
Once it’s set up, a full RegData Report can be completed in under 30 minutes. That’s the difference between compliance being a quiet background task and being the thing that ruins your month. If you want a fuller picture of how this shifts the work, why RegData reporting isn't the problem is a good place to start.
On the payroll side, MyPAYE does the same job for employers and bureaux. RTI submissions, auto-enrolment, statutory pay, CIS, P11Ds all handled in one place, with HMRC sitting at the other end of it rather than at the end of a spreadsheet. For firms that are growing quickly, payroll and compliance is usually the first thing to break, and getting it right early saves a lot of pain later.
If you’d like to see how MyPAYE and MyRegData could fit into the way your firm works, get in touch with the team on 0161 413 5050 or book a no-obligation demo.
Sign up for a free trial today and see how our cloud accounting software can benefit your business.
You might also like
Changes and updates to Tax and National Insurance Rates coming into effect on 6th January 2024.
Within the statement released by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, was a rundown of changes being implemented in how National Insurance is paid, which means there are some key points to note which can help avoid costly payroll mistakes after the new year.
Cloud accounting vs desktop software: what businesses really gain
For many businesses, desktop accounting software has been the backbone of their finances for years. It’s familiar, it works and changing it can feel like an unnecessary risk. But as businesses become more flexible and teams work in different ways, the limits of desktop systems are becoming harder to ignore. That’s why more organisations are now considering cloud accounting, not as a trend, but as a practical step forward.
Finance software’s that work for charities
Running a charity comes with enough challenges without financial admin slowing things down. From managing donations and grants to paying staff and volunteers correctly, finance teams need charity finance software that is reliable, easy to use and compliant with regulations.
Free Yourself from Fees: Why Small Businesses Should Take Control of Payroll with MyPAYE
As a small business owner, you wear many hats. Marketing, sales, operations, the buck stops with you. But payroll?
How payroll slows firms down and how to fix it
Payroll is one of those business processes that simply has to work. Employees expect to be paid correctly and on time, and employers need to stay compliant with HMRC regulations. But for many small and growing businesses, payroll is still a regular source of stress, delays and unnecessary admin.
How to make FCA RegData reporting quick and simple
For many IFAs, FCA RegData reporting is one of those jobs that always feels bigger than it should. It’s detailed, time-consuming and often left until the last minute simply because fitting it around client work is difficult. The good news? RegData reporting doesn’t have to take days of preparation or involve juggling spreadsheets, bookkeeping systems and forms. With the right approach and tools, it can be quick, straightforward and far less stressful.
Payroll accuracy challenges for small businesses and how payroll software helps
Running a small business is never straightforward. There are sales to chase, customers to please and countless administrative tasks to manage. Payroll is one of the trickiest areas and it’s one that can quickly spiral into errors if you’re not careful. Even a simple mistake can lead to compliance issues, unhappy employees or fines from HMRC. So why do so many small businesses struggle with payroll accuracy and what can you do to fix it?
Payroll year end: What you need to do now
With the payroll year ending on 5 April, now’s the time to make sure everything is wrapped up properly and you’re ready to hit the ground running in the new tax year.
Post year-end payroll mistakes to avoid
The start of a new tax year is always a busy time for businesses. With the 2026/27 tax year now underway, many employers are already settling into new payroll routines, updating records and making sure everything submitted at year-end was accurate and complete. But even after the year-end deadline has passed, payroll mistakes can still create problems. From incorrect employee data to missed HMRC submissions, small errors can lead to unnecessary stress, delays and potential penalties.
Scaling your business? Payroll and compliance will break first
Growth is the goal. More customers, more hires, more momentum. But there’s one part of the business that rarely gets any attention until it starts causing problems and that’s payroll. Early on, it feels simple enough. A spreadsheet, a few employees, a monthly routine that doesn’t take long to run. It’s manageable, so it gets pushed down the priority list. The focus stays on sales, delivery and everything driving the business forward.
Switching Payroll Providers Mid-Year? No Sweat!
Let’s be real - payroll is all about keeping things smooth and efficient. And if you’ve ever thought about switching payroll providers, you’ve probably heard the same old advice: "Wait until the new tax year in April!" But here’s the thing—that advice might be more myth than must-do. Sure, April gives you a "clean slate" with fresh year-to-date figures, but is it really the best time to make the switch? Let’s break it down.
The hidden cost of doing payroll manually
For a lot of small businesses, payroll starts off simple. A spreadsheet here, a few calculations there, maybe a bit of back-and-forth with HMRC. It feels manageable… until it isn’t. That’s when the manual payroll risks start to build up in the background. What often gets missed isn’t just the time it takes, it’s the hidden cost that builds up in the background.
Update to Scottish Income Tax Rates for 2024-25
The key income tax changes taking force from 6 April 2024 in Scotland were announced by the SNP’s Finance Secretary, Shona Robison, as she released a new plan for Scottish income tax rates which will impact payroll operations. The Scottish Government also announced a newly introduced 45 per cent income tax band for people earning between £75,000 and £125,140 per year.
What is a P11D Form – and why is it so important to payroll compliance?
Why RegData reporting isn’t the problem
Speak to most IFAs about RegData reporting and the reaction is fairly similar. It’s seen as time-consuming, complicated and something that takes up far more headspace than it should.
Why RMAR reporting takes hours
For many IFAs and regulated firms, RMAR reporting is one of those tasks that quietly eats up hours every reporting period.